Key Lessons

Proper management of patients with Type I diabetes, particularly on insulin pumps, during and after surgery requires clear protocols, specialist consultation as necessary, and effective communication among the care team to prevent avoidable complications.

Description

Post-op management of an insulin pump in a patient with Type I diabetes results in diabetic ketoacidosis (DKA) and myocardial infarction (MI).

Clinical Sequence

A 56-year-old male with a history of Type I diabetes mellitus (DM), managed with an insulin pump, and peripheral vascular disease was admitted for a femoral-popliteal bypass graft. After the procedure, the patient was transferred to the Post-Operative Care Unit (PACU). Despite having Type I diabetes and being on an insulin pump, endocrinology was not consulted. Without orders from the vascular surgeon, the nurse instructed the patient’s wife to turn off the pump because the patient was sedated and unable to self-bolus. The patient was to be covered with sliding scale insulin (SSI). About an hour later, the patient’s blood sugar was 197. The vascular surgeon was called and they asked the nurse practitioner (NP) to order insulin but, due to busyness, the insulin was never ordered or given. Documentation of these discussions did not exist.

The patient’s blood sugar was 284 when transferred to the floor, and the vascular surgeon was not called. It is unclear whether the admitting team knew the insulin pump was off. Transfer orders included SSI and finger sticks with meals and at bedtime, so he was given one unit of insulin (type unknown). No further testing was done until the following morning when his blood sugar was 434. A rapid response team was called, an insulin drip was started, and the patient was transferred to the ICU for DKA. Serial cardiac enzymes indicated the patient had suffered an MI.

Allegation

The patient alleged a failure of the vascular surgeon to obtain an endocrinology consult resulting in mismanagement of his diabetes and subsequent DKA.

Disposition

The case was settled in the medium range (approx. $250,000).

Clinical Analysis

The surgeon failed to obtain an endocrinology consult for managing the patient’s Type I diabetes.

  • Patients with Type I diabetes on an insulin pump receive a continuous basal rate of insulin 24 hours a day. Removing the insulin pump requires replacing the equivalent amount of Lantus or Levemir in two divided doses, 12 hours apart.
  • Boluses of insulin should be given according to carbohydrate ratio.

The patient’s blood sugars were inadequately monitored.

  • The patient’s finger stick was not repeated after giving the 1 unit of insulin for the blood sugar of 284. A blood sugar of that level in a patient with Type I DM requires more frequent monitoring given they are not receiving their basal dose.

There was a lack of communication among providers.

  • The RN did not discuss the management of the insulin pump with the vascular surgeon.
  • The surgeon was not called when the patient’s blood sugar rose.

Discussion Questions

  1. What policies/procedures are in place to manage patients with Type I diabetes on an insulin pump?
  2. Is there an algorithm for when a patient is not able to manage their insulin pump?
  3. Does a preoperative plan exist for managing patients with Type I diabetes?

Resources


This is a fictitious case that illustrates commonly encountered issues and is for educational purposes only. Any resemblance to real persons, living or dead, is purely coincidental.


See More MPL Cases

CRICO’s case studies educate you on what can go wrong in business settings and how you can prevent similar issues.
    EPL Jan 2026

    Retaliation Allegation after Mental Health Leave

    Case Study
    Hospital employee alleges retaliation after returning from FMLA leave.
    A woman gently rests her hand on the shoulder of an elderly person, both smiling, in a cozy setting with soft colors

    Incidental Does Not Mean Insignificant

    Case Study
    Ordering providers were not informed of an incidental finding on a chest computer tomography (CT) scan, resulting in a delayed lung cancer diagnosis that ultimately metastasized and caused the patient’s death.
    In a hospital gown, a woman holds an MRI scan, examining it closely in a healthcare facility

    When Test Results Go Unspoken

    Case Study
    An abnormal finding from a computed tomography angiogram (CTA) scan was not communicated to the patient, leading to a delayed diagnosis of lung cancer and shortened life expectancy.
X
Cookies help us improve your website experience.
By using our website, you agree to our use of cookies.
Confirm